1
$\begingroup$

Suppose a composite system $AB$ initially in an unknown quantum state $\rho$ is brought into contact with a composite system $CD$ initially in some standard state $|0\rangle$, and the two systems interact according to a unitary interaction $U$. After the interaction we discard systems $A$ and $D$, leaving a state $\rho\:'$ of the system $BC$. Show that the map $\mathcal{E}(\rho)=\rho\:'$ satisfies $$ \mathcal{E}(\rho)=\sum_k E_k\rho E_k^\dagger $$ for some set of linear operators $E_k$ from the state space of system $AB$ to the state space of system $BC$, and such that $\sum_kE_k^\dagger E_k=I$.

This is given, in Exercise 8.3, Page 361, Operator-sum representation, Chapter 8, Quantum Computation and Quantum Information by Nielsen and Chuang.

Overall state of the system after the interaction is $U(\rho\otimes|0\rangle\langle 0|)U^\dagger$

Let $|a_m\rangle,|b_n\rangle,|c_p\rangle,|d_q\rangle$ be orthonormal basis for the state space of the systems $A,B,C,D$, respectively.

Discarding systems $A$ and $D$, i.e., tracing out system $A$ first then tracing out the system $D$ obtains

\begin{align} \mathcal{E}(&\rho)=tr_D\Big[tr_A\big[U(\rho\otimes|0\rangle\langle 0|)U^\dagger\big]\Big]\\ &=tr_D\Big[\sum_m(\langle a_m|\otimes I\otimes I\otimes I) \big[U(\rho\otimes|0\rangle\langle 0|)U^\dagger\big](|a_m\rangle\otimes I\otimes I\otimes I)\Big]\\ &=\sum_q(I\otimes I\otimes I\otimes \langle d_q|)\\ &\times\Big[\sum_m(\langle a_m|\otimes I\otimes I\otimes I) \big[U(\rho\otimes|0\rangle\langle 0|)U^\dagger\big](|a_m\rangle\otimes I\otimes I\otimes I)\Big](I\otimes I\otimes I\otimes |d_q\rangle)\\ &=\sum_{m,q}(\langle a_m|\otimes I\otimes I\otimes \langle d_q|) \big[U(\rho\otimes|0\rangle\langle 0|)U^\dagger\big](|a_m\rangle\otimes I\otimes I\otimes |d_q\rangle) \end{align}

Expanding $\rho\otimes|0\rangle\langle 0|$ into the products

\begin{align} \rho\otimes|0\rangle\langle 0|&=\rho_{AB}\otimes|0_{CD}\rangle\langle 0_{CD}|=\color{blue}{(\rho_{AB}\otimes I_{CD})(I_{AB}\otimes|0_{CD}\rangle)}(I_{AB}\otimes\langle 0_{CD}|)\\ =&\color{blue}{(\rho_{AB}I_{AB}\otimes I_{CD}|0_{CD}\rangle)}(I_{AB}\otimes\langle 0_{CD}|)=\color{blue}{(I_{AB}\rho_{AB}\otimes |0_{CD}\rangle.1)}(I_{AB}\otimes\langle 0_{CD}|)\\ =&\color{blue}{(I_{AB}\otimes |0_{CD}\rangle)(\rho_{AB}\otimes 1)}(I_{AB}\otimes\langle 0_{CD}|)=\color{blue}{(I_{AB}\otimes |0_{CD}\rangle)\rho_{AB}}(I_{AB}\otimes\langle 0_{CD}|)\\ =&\color{blue}{(I_{AB}\otimes |0_{CD}\rangle)\rho}(I_{AB}\otimes\langle 0_{CD}|) \end{align} Substituting back into the expression, \begin{align} \mathcal{E}(&\rho)=\\\\ =&\sum_{m,q}(\langle a_m|\otimes I\otimes I\otimes \langle d_q|) U(I_{AB}\otimes |0_{CD}\rangle)\rho(I_{AB}\otimes\langle 0_{CD}|)U^\dagger(|a_m\rangle\otimes I\otimes I\otimes |d_q\rangle)\\\\ =&\sum_{m,q} E_{m,q}\rho E_{m,q}^\dagger \end{align} where $E_{m,q}=\langle a_m|\otimes I\otimes I\otimes \langle d_q|) U(I_{AB}\otimes |0_{CD}\rangle)$

\begin{align} &\color{red} {\text{How do I show that this is a linear operator from the state space of $AB$ to the state}}\\ &\color{red} {\text{ space of $BC$ ?}} \end{align} My Attempt

If $|a_m\rangle,|b_n\rangle,|c_p\rangle,|d_q\rangle$ be orthonormal basis for the state space of the systems $\mathbb{C}^{i},\mathbb{C}^{j},\mathbb{C}^{k},\mathbb{C}^{l}$ respectively, then $|a_m\rangle\otimes|b_n\rangle\otimes|c_p\rangle\otimes|d_q\rangle$ is an orthonormal basis for the combined system $\mathbb{C}^{i}\otimes\mathbb{C}^{j}\otimes\mathbb{C}^{k}\otimes\mathbb{C}^{l}=\mathbb{C}^{ijkl}$. \begin{align} &\color{gray}{\text{Lemma: If $V$ and $W$ are vector spaces with basis $|v_i\rangle$ and $|w_j\rangle$ respectively. Then }}\\ &\color{gray}{|v_i\rangle\otimes_{outer}|w_j\rangle=|v_i\rangle\langle w_j| \text{form a basis for the vector space $V\otimes_{outer}W$.}} \end{align} Therefore, $(|a_m\rangle\otimes|b_n\rangle\otimes|c_p\rangle\otimes|d_q\rangle)(\langle a_{m'}|\otimes\langle b_{n'}|\otimes\langle c_{p'}|\otimes\langle d_{q'}|)=|a_m\rangle\langle a_{m'}|\otimes|b_n\rangle\langle b_{n'}|\otimes|c_p\rangle\langle c_{p'}|\otimes|d_q\rangle\langle d_{q'}|$ for a basis for the space $\mathbb{C}^{ijkl}\otimes_{outer}\mathbb{C}^{ijkl}$.

$\therefore U\in\mathbb{C}^{ijkl}\otimes_{outer}\mathbb{C}^{ijkl}$ can be written as a linear combination of the basis $(|a_m\rangle\otimes|b_n\rangle\otimes|c_p\rangle\otimes|d_q\rangle)(\langle a_{m'}|\otimes\langle b_{n'}|\otimes\langle c_{p'}|\otimes\langle d_{q'}|)=|a_m\rangle\langle a_{m'}|\otimes|b_n\rangle\langle b_{n'}|\otimes|c_p\rangle\langle c_{p'}|\otimes|d_q\rangle\langle d_{q'}|$.

i.e., $$ U=\sum_{m',n',p',q'}\nu_{m',n',p',q'} (|a_{m'}\rangle\otimes|b_{n'}\rangle\otimes|c_{p'}\rangle\otimes|d_{q'}\rangle)(\langle a_{m''}|\otimes\langle b_{n''}|\otimes\langle c_{p''}|\otimes\langle d_{q''}|)\\ =\sum_{m',n',p',q'}\nu_{m',n',p',q'} |a_{m'}\rangle\langle a_{m''}|\otimes|b_{n'}\rangle\langle b_{n''}|\otimes|c_{p'}\rangle\langle c_{p''}|\otimes|d_{q'}\rangle\langle d_{q''}| $$

And $|0_{CD}\rangle$ being a standard state of the system $CD$ can be represented in terms of the orthonormal basis vectors as, $$ |0_{CD}\rangle=\sum_{p,q}\eta_{p,q} |c_p\rangle\otimes|d_q\rangle $$

Substituting back into the expression for $E_{m,q}$ obtains \begin{align} &E_{m,q}=\\ &=\langle a_m|\otimes I\otimes I\otimes \langle d_q|) U(I_{AB}\otimes |0_{CD}\rangle)\\ &=\langle a_m|\otimes I_B\otimes I_C\otimes \langle d_q|) U\sum_{p''',q'''}\eta_{p''',q'''}(I_{A}\otimes I_{B}\otimes|c_{p'''}\rangle\otimes|d_{q'''}\rangle)\\ &=\langle a_m|\otimes I_B\otimes I_C\otimes \langle d_q|)\Big[ \sum_{m',n',p',q'\\m'',n'',p'',q''}\nu_{m',n',p',q'\\m'',n'',p'',q''} |a_{m'}\rangle\langle a_{m''}|\otimes|b_{n'}\rangle\langle b_{n''}|\otimes|c_{p'}\rangle\langle c_{p''}|\otimes|d_{q'}\rangle\langle d_{q''}|\Big]\\ &\times\sum_{p''',q'''}\eta_{p''',q'''}(I_{A}\otimes I_{B}\otimes|c_{p'''}\rangle\otimes|d_{q'''}\rangle)\\ &=\langle a_m|\otimes I_B\otimes I_C\otimes \langle d_q|)\Big[ \sum_{m',n',p',q'\\m'',n'',p'',q''}\sum_{p''',q'''}\eta_{p''',q'''}\nu_{m',n',p',q'\\m'',n'',p'',q''} |a_{m'}\rangle\langle a_{m''}|\otimes|b_{n'}\rangle\langle b_{n''}|\otimes|c_{p'}\rangle\langle c_{p''}|\otimes|d_{q'}\rangle\langle d_{q''}|\Big]\\ &\times(I_{A}\otimes I_{B}\otimes|c_{p'''}\rangle\otimes|d_{q'''}\rangle)\\ \\ &=\sum_{m',n',p',q'\\m'',n'',p'',q''}\sum_{p''',q'''}\eta_{p''',q'''}\nu_{m',n',p',q'\\m'',n'',p'',q''} \langle a_{m}|a_{m'}\rangle\langle a_{m''}|\otimes|b_{n'}\rangle\langle b_{n''}|\otimes|c_{p'}\rangle\langle c_{p''}|c_{p'''}\rangle\otimes\langle d_{q}|d_{q'}\rangle\langle d_{q''}|d_{q'''}\rangle\\ \\ &=\sum_{m',n',p',q'\\m'',n'',p'',q''}\sum_{p''',q'''}\eta_{p''',q'''}\nu_{m',n',p',q'\\m'',n'',p'',q''} \delta_{m,m'}\langle a_{m''}|\otimes|b_{n'}\rangle\langle b_{n''}|\otimes|c_{p'}\rangle\delta_{p'',p'''}\otimes\delta_{q,q'}\delta_{q'',q'''}\\ \\ &=\sum_{n',p',q,m'',n'',p'',q''}\eta_{p'',q''}\nu_{m,n',p',q\\m'',n'',p''} \langle a_{m''}|\otimes|b_{n'}\rangle\langle b_{n''}|\otimes|c_{p'}\rangle\otimes 1\\ &=\sum_{n',p',q,m'',n'',p'',q''}\eta_{p'',q''}\nu_{m,n',p',q\\m'',n'',p''} (1.\langle a_{m''}|\otimes|b_{n'}\rangle\langle b_{n''}|\otimes|c_{p'}\rangle.1\otimes 1.1)\\ &=\sum_{n',p',q,m'',n'',p'',q''}\eta_{p'',q''}\nu_{m,n',p',q\\m'',n'',p''} (1\otimes|b_{n'}\rangle\otimes|c_{p'}\rangle\otimes 1)(\langle a_{m''}|\otimes\langle b_{n''}|\otimes 1\otimes 1)\\\end{align}

$\implies E_{m,q}$ is a sum of operators from $AB$ to $BC$.

$\endgroup$
0

1 Answer 1

1
$\begingroup$

If I understand correctly, you want to show that $$ E_{m,q}=(\langle a_m|\otimes I_B\otimes I_C\otimes \langle d_q|) U(I_{A}\otimes I_B\otimes |0_{C}\rangle\otimes |0_{D}\rangle) $$ is a linear operator from $AB$ to $CD$.

For this, you can just expand the identity operators in the expression. E.g. $I_B=\sum_i |i_B\rangle\!\langle i_B|$ for any orthonormal basis $\{|i_B\rangle\}_i$ for the space $B$, and same for the other identities. You'll end up with an expression of the form $$E_{m,q} = \sum_{ijk\ell} c_{ijk\ell} (|i_B\rangle\otimes|j_C\rangle)(\langle k_A|\otimes \langle\ell_B|)$$ for some set of numbers $c_{ijk\ell}$. This is a linear operator between the relevant spaces.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.