How to rigorously prove that finite Hamiltonians (for $n$-qubit systems), in general, are not efficiently$\dagger$ simulable (in the Hamiltonian simulation sense) using $\mathrm{poly}(n)$ number of quantum gates?
1 Answer
Perhaps not absolutely rigorous, but....
We know that the vast majority of unitaries require exponentially large circuits. So, define $H=i\ln U$. The vast majority of these Hamiltonians take exponentially long to simulate. While there is ambiguity in taking the log, it doesn’t matter how you choose to resolve that ambiguity because they are all “bad”.